Andrew, I agree with your point of view, however this does not rule out the PX-5S for me. I am more interested in how the board sounds compared to the PX-3. I also own a PX-3 and sometimes use a Behringer fcb1010 to control swells and volume using midi - but it is a real pain and introduces other limitations so I try and avoid doing this if at all possible. This means that I do not use the PX-3, usually, as a master controller but primarily as a stage piano. There would appear to be a couple of 'tricks' that have been introduced with the PX-5S to allow layers to be brought in - albeit not in a totally 'flexible' manner. We will have to wait and see how these work in practice. I am also waiting to see the midi implementation for the PX-5S to see what may be possible. Will